Skip to main content

Gathering Eldest Daughters

Our season is here. And yes, I’m a October Libra! ♎

As an eldest daughter, I have spent a lot of my life making sure everybody is good.

Did everyone eat?
Did everybody get home?
Does anybody need anything?
Are we okay?
Is there a problem?
Can I fix it?

Very Libra of me, honestly.

 

Libras get associated with balance, harmony, and fairness. Eldest daughters? A lot of us get plenty of practice trying to keep everybody good. Put those together, and you might get someone who walks into a room, picks up on every mood, and starts adjusting herself before anyone has asked her to.

This week was my birthday, and birthdays have a way of making you look at the life you’ve built and the roles you got very good at playing inside it. And this year, I keep coming back to the difference between keeping the peace and being at peace.

They are not the same thing.

 

Keeping the peace has a cost

Keeping the peace is a skill. Many of us learned it early. In a lot of immigrant households, the eldest daughter becomes the translator, the second parent, the one who smooths things over so the family can keep moving.

And for a long time, it works. People feel comfortable around you. You’re “easy.” You’re “the reliable one.”

But here is what nobody tells you:

Sometimes everybody is comfortable because you swallowed what you wanted to say.

Sometimes you can see everybody’s side so clearly that people forget you have one, too.

Sometimes being “easygoing” means nobody has to make room for you.

In a lot of our cultures, respect and silence get tangled together.

Speaking up can look like disrespect. Asking a question can look like talking back. Setting a boundary can look like you forgot where you came from.

And saying nothing? That gets called peace.

But it isn’t peace to me. Silence that costs me myself is not peace. It’s just quiet.

Standing up for myself doesn’t mean I don’t care about the people around me. It means I’m learning that their comfort and my peace don’t always require the same thing.

For me, being at peace isn’t about the room being calm. It’s about being able to stay connected to myself even when someone else is disappointed, even when not everyone understands, even when I choose myself.

 

Multiple things can be true

One thing I keep learning, and relearning, and learning again is that multiple things can be true at the same time.

Culture and community can be beautiful. They can also hold things that hurt us. They are complex, and for so many of us, they are foundational to our lives.

We don’t all move through them the same way. Some of us follow tradition. Some of us question the rules. Some of us challenge the patriarchy and get punished for it. I have been more than one of those, sometimes in the same week. And some of us are changing things for the younger generations without even knowing it yet.

We plant seeds. Sometimes we get to see them grow. Sometimes we don’t.

But we know we planted them.

There is no one right way to be an eldest daughter inside your culture. Every path has its own weight, grief, and gifts.

I can love where I come from and still name what hurt.

I can be grateful for what my family gave me and still grieve what I had to carry.

Holding both is not betrayal. It’s honesty.

 

The work I did this year

This year, part of my healing meant facing the past.

Not just remembering it, but making space to feel and process its impact so I could start letting go and moving forward.

I won’t pretend it was easy. It was exhausting. It hurt.

And it was needed.

You can’t skip straight to the part where you’re at peace. Sometimes you have to go back and make sense of what you’ve been carrying before you can decide what you’re ready to put down.

Mistakes used to make me literally sick to my stomach. I would obsess over them. This year, I noticed I had stopped rehearsing old conversations in my head. I was no longer picking apart my words and actions, trying to make sure I never said or did the wrong thing.

So when I say I’m walking into this birthday differently, I mean it. I’m walking in a little lighter because I finally put some things down.

 

Letting go of the need to be understood

Part of putting things down has been recognizing how much energy I’ve spent trying to prove myself to people who have already decided how they see me.

Explaining. Over-explaining. Hoping that if I found the right words, something would finally click.

It’s exhausting.

 

I’m learning that I can’t explain my way into being understood by someone who isn’t willing to understand me.

I’m learning when to stop trying.

I don’t have to spend all my energy trying to change how people see me.

I want to make more room for the people who love me as I am, and for the parts of my life I’ve been too busy managing to fully enjoy.

 

 

The birthday I almost overthought

Of course, old habits still show up.

It took me a long time to figure out what I wanted to do for my birthday this year. Travel? I thought about it. Then I looked at prices and remembered NOT in this damn economy.

I scrolled Eventbrite for inspiration. I checked in with friends on dates we could go on a boat. I made plans. Then I didn’t follow through on them. By the time i looked into it again the boat was booked. That happened, more than once.

Looking back, I think I was trying to find the “right” birthday: the one that looked good, made sense, and worked for everyone.

What I finally landed on was simple. And it was perfect for me.

My birthday was on a Monday, and the celebrating started Sunday with a birthday brunch surrounded by SUN, love, fun, and so much laughter. Because apparently, one day isn’t always enough for us Libras. 🤎

On my actual birthday, I spent the day at the pool with people I love. Music playing. Being in the water with nowhere to be and nothing to manage. Then I had an amazing dinner with my love.

 

No big production. No coordinating the whole experience for everybody else. Just me, my needs, my people, and joy.

It was amazing.

I didn’t need a trip to prove the birthday mattered. I needed a pool, music, good food, and people who were happy to be with me.

A lot of eldest daughters believe joy has to be earned. We’ll rest after everything is done, celebrate after everyone else is okay, and do something for ourselves when there’s finally room.

But everything is never done. And joy that waits for permission usually waits forever.

My wishes for myself this year

To follow through. I have so many ideas. This year, I want to act on more of them and put them out into the world, including here, more often.

To pace myself. There is no rush. Healing doesn’t have a deadline, and neither does building something meaningful. Slow and steady still gets there.

To stop treating every flaw like a problem to solve. I’d rather be here, imperfect, than perfect and missing it.

To focus on the people who love me. More time pouring into the people who pour into me. I can care about people without taking responsibility for managing how they feel about me.

I’m still figuring a lot of things out. I’m letting myself enjoy where I am anyway.

For you, eldest daughter

If you’re reading this and recognizing yourself, here are a few questions to sit with:

  1. Where are you keeping the peace instead of being at peace?
  2. What two things are true for you right now, even if they seem like they shouldn’t be able to exist together?
  3. What have you been wanting to do that you keep putting off?
  4. Whose opinion of you are you still trying to change?

You don’t have to answer all of them. Even noticing is a start.

And if your birthday is coming up, maybe start with one question:

What do I actually want? Not what would make the best plan, what would make everyone happy, or what would look good. What would feel good to you?

You can make space for what you want before everybody else is good.

 

Here’s to another year of making room for the people I love and remembering that I belong in the room, too.

Happy Libra season. 🤎♎

 

Until the next gathering,

Rest when you can.
Take up space.
Exhale fully.

— Gathering Eldest Daughters

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *